Re: [council] Results of vote on Motion to the UDRP Review and Evaluation ToR

["erica" <erica.roberts@bigpond.com>]

It is my understanding that a majority of the NC is required for any motion
ot be adopted.  Given that there are 21 NC members, we need more than 9 in
favour to pass a motion.

Perhaps the Chair or Secretatriat could clarify the voting requirements..

erica
----- Original Message -----
From: "DNSO Secretariat" <DNSO.Secretariat@dnso.org>
To: <council@dnso.org>
Sent: Sunday, August 12, 2001 4:17 AM
Subject: [council] Results of vote on Motion to the UDRP Review and
Evaluation ToR


>
> 11 August 2001, 20:00 UTC (22:00 Paris time)
>
> Re: b07
>
> Vote by the Names Council on Motion to the UDRP Review and Evaluation ToR.
>
> Vote result:
> Fifteen NC members out of twenty one (15 out of 21) took part to vote,
> 71 percent.
> The motion is adopted by 9 "agree", 1 "disagree", 5 "abstain".
>
> DNSO Secretariat
> --
>
>
>
> Motion:
> -------
> Motion moved by Milton Mueller, seconded by Tony Holmes:
>
>  The provision in the UDRP Review Terms of Reference
>  excluding from participation members of the "small
>  drafting committee" that worked on the original
>  UDRP is rescinded.
>
> The UDRP Review and Evaluation, Terms of Reference,
> were adopted during the NC teleconference on 29 July 2001, cf:
> http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/20010629.NCtelecon-minutes.html
>
>       Decision D2: UDRP Interim Group recommendations were
>       accepted with two additional items:
>
>        - all individual that had participated in a drafting
>          of the original UDRP should be excluded from this process;
>
>        - an independent expert as an additional TF member.
>
> The adopted UDRP Review and Evaluation ToR are quoted in minutes, also at
> http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.NC-tor-UDRP-Review-Evaluation.html
>
> The time for this NC vote was:
> ------------------------------
>     Starting Friday,  03 August 2001, 09:30 Paris time (07:30 UTC), now,
>     Ending   Friday,  10 August 2001, 23:59 your local time
>              or when all 21 ballots from the NC has been received,
>              whatever occurs first.
> The results were due no later than 11 August 2001, 24:00
> Paris time (22:00 UTC).
>
> The complete vote record:
> -------------------------
>
> Ballot sent with       3 choices
>            b07:[ ] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>            b07:[ ] I disagree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>            b07:[ ] I abstain
>
> Electorate of      21 persons, casting one vote each
> Ballots received from      15 persons (sorted by arrival time)
>            Elisabeth Porteneuve
>            Philip Sheppard
>            Ken Stubbs
>            Peter de Blanc
>            Antonio Harris
>            Milton Mueller
>            Greg Ruth
>            Guillermo Carey
>            Erica Roberts
>            Grant Forsyth
>            Youn Jung Park
>            Axel Aus der Muhlen
>            Roger Cochetti
>            Caroline Chicoine
>            Nilda Vany Martinez Grajales
>
> Casted votes (sorted by personal code)
>            b07:K10d1Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:K12e2Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:K140cZ casted  1 votes
>            b07:K1709Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:K1a3dZ casted  0 votes
>            b07:K3018Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:K4902Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:K601cZ casted  1 votes
>            b07:K84b3Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:K85cbZ casted  1 votes
>            b07:Ka40cZ casted  1 votes
>            b07:Kc0efZ casted  1 votes
>            b07:Kd531Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:Kdec6Z casted  1 votes
>            b07:Kf67fZ casted  1 votes
>
> Nb of casted votes      14
> Vote results, full list:
>            9 I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>            4 I abstain
>            1 I disagree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>            1 empty ballot
> The empty ballot is counted as "abstain".
>
> Public results (sorted by personal code)
>  b07:K10d1Z:[X] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K12e2Z:[ x ] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K140cZ:[ x] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K1709Z:[X] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K3018Z:[X] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K4902Z:[X ] I abstain
>  b07:K601cZ:[X ] I abstain
>  b07:K84b3Z:[X ] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K85cbZ:[X] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:Ka40cZ:[ X] I abstain
>  b07:Kc0efZ:[X] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:Kd531Z:[X] I abstain
>  b07:Kdec6Z:[x ] I agree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:Kf67fZ:[x ] I disagree on the UDRP Review ToR motion
>  b07:K1a3dZ:    abstention
>
> --