Re: [council] NCtelecon 21 September 2000, minutes

[Dany Vandromme <vandrome@renater.fr>]

On Sat, 30 Sep 2000, YJ Park wrote:

> 
> > personally, i feel that any opinions expressed by any member need to be
> more
> > explicitly attributed  ( particularly for example  those made by YJ when
> she
> > referred to hypocracy).  if those are her opinions then they need to be
> > attributed to her in a way such as "yj stated that she felt ...xxxx.
> 
> OK with me.:-)
> 
> > i would also like to say that i do not believe that YJ speaks for the
> entire
> > GA as a whole but rather for a specific segment. the broad allusions that
> > she makes do not necessarily represent those of  many ga members. yj seems
> > to forget that members of all constituancies are also members of the ga.
> she
> > may or may not reflect the views of her constituancy but she certainly
> does
> > not reflect the views of all the ga.
> 
> In principle, Roberto represents GA and I do non-commercial constituency.
> However, all the comments made by myself was as a member of review
> committee who has to cover not only his/her specific interest group but also
> across the constituencies and its related organizations.
> 
> I don't think it was beyond the scope.
> That's within the scope of the review committee.
> 
> Otherwise, how can you review the whole DNSO process?
> 
> >  there are numerous people who do not subscribe to the various ga list
> (for
> > varying reasons including noise etc) so when yj says the ga feels this or
> > that she is only reflecting a very small part of the total universe and i
> > feel that this needs to be pointed out so that when yj goes " on the
> record"
> > we as well as the readers know just exactly "who" she is going on the
> record
> > for.
> 
> In this sense, icann itself still represents a very small part of the total
> universe, too.
> The people we are represent are not the whole WORLD at all.
> 
> > based on the comments i made above i personally cannot vote to accept the
> > minutes as presented without the specific reservations quoted above.
> 
> I think your reservation can be removed.
> 
> YJ
> 
> > respectfully
> >
> > ken stubbs
> > speaking for himself  and as a member of the council, the registrar
> > constituancy and a member of the ga)
> >
-
I do support YJ position for this. She was commenting as member of the
review committee subgroup, and not strictly as the voice of a single
constituency.
-


--------------------------------------------------------------------
Dany VANDROMME                    |  Directeur du GIP RENATER

                Reseau National de Telecommunications 
         pour la Technologie, l'Enseignement et la Recherche

                                  |  ENSAM
Tel   :  +33 (0)1 53 94 20 30     |  151 Boulevard de l'Hopital
Fax   :  +33 (0)1 53 94 20 31     |  75013 Paris
E-mail: Dany.Vandromme@renater.fr |  FRANCE
--------------------------------------------------------------------