[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[wg-c] Administrivia (11/12)



Two parts: yes/no count followed by my personal prognostication.

As usual, errors to me.
Eric

110 subscribers of list 'wg-c' (as of 8 Dec 1999):
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
name			| 6-10	| paper	| 8 Dec	|	|	|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
YES votes (36)
Andrew Lutts            |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Ann-Catherine Andersson |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Astrid Broich	        |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Craig Simon	        |	| F	|YES	|	|	|
Daiva Tamulioniene      |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Dave Crocker	        |	| A,D  	|YES	|	|	|
David Maher	        |	| A,D 	|YES	|	|	|
Eric Brunner	        |	| A,D,E	|YES	|	|	|
Greg Maxon	        |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Hal Lubsen	        |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Harold Feld	        |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Ian Penman	        |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Jay Parker (WICG)       |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Jeff Shrewsbury	        |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
John Charles Broomfield |	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Joop Teernstra	        |	| B	|YES	|	|	|
Joseph Friedman		|	| A,D  	|YES	|	|	|
Karl Auerbach		|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Kathryn Vestal		|	| B  	|YES	|	|	|
Ken Stubbs		|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Kilnam Chon		|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Mark Langston		|	| B  	|YES	|	|	|
Mikki  Barry		|	| B	|YES	|	|	|
Milton Mueller		|	| B	|YES	|	|	|
Olivier Kozlowski      	|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Paul Garrin		|	| B  	|YES	|	|	|
Rebecca Nesson		|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Richard Lindsay		|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Rick H. Wesson		|	|  	|YES	|	|	|
Robert F. Connelly     	|	| A	|YES	|	|	|
Rod Dixon		|	| A,B 	|YES	|	|	|
Roeland Meyer		|	| G	|YES	|	|	|
Siegfried Langenbach    |	| A  	|YES	|	|	|
Timothy M. Denton      	|	| B  	|YES	|	|	|
Werner Staub		|	|	|YES	|	|	|
William X. Walsh      	|	| B  	|YES	|	|	|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
name			| 6-10	| paper	| 8 Dec	|	|	|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NO votes (9)
Caroline Chicoine       |       | C	|NO	|	|	|
Keith Gymer		|	| C	|NO	|	|	|
Kevin J. Connolly      	|	|  	|NO	|	|	|
Michael Palage		|	|  	|NO	|	|	|
Otho Ross               |	|  	|NO	|	|	|
Petter Rindforth      	|       | C	|NO	|	|	|
Philip Sheppard		|	|  	|NO	|	|	|
Scott Pollard		|	|  	|NO	|	|	|
Tod Cohen		|	| C	|NO	|	|	|

END ADMINISTRIVIA (what follows is non-non-partizan)

Votes I'm expecting:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
name                    | 6-10  | paper | 8 Dec |       |       |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A.M. Rutkowski          |       | B     | yes	|       |       |
Amadeu Abril i Abril    |       |       | yes 1 |       |       |
Amar Andersson          |       | A,D   | yes   |       |       |
Annie Renard            |       | C     | no    |       |       |
Anthony Lupo            |       | C     | no    |       |       |
...
Christopher Ambler      |       | B     | yes   |       |       |
...
Elisabeth Porteneuve    |       |       | yes   |       |       |
...
J. William Semich       |       |       | yes   |       |       |
Javier Sola             |       | D     | yes   |       |       |
Jean-Michel Becar       |       | A     | yes   |       |       |
Jim Glanz               |       | D     | yes   |       |       |
Jonathan Weinberg       |       | A     | yes   |       |       |
...
Kent Crispin            |       | D,E   | yes   |       |       |
...
Marilyn Cade            |       | C     | yes 2 |       |       |
Mark A. Sportack        |       |       | yes 2 |       |       |
Mark Measday            |       | A     | yes   |       |       |
Martin Schwimmer        |       | C     | no    |       |       |
Matt Hooker             |       |       | no 4  |       |       |
...
Paul Stahura            |       | A     | yes   |       |       |
...
Rita M. Odin            |       | C     | no    |       |       |


[1] I'm guessing that if Amadeu votes it will be as a Catalan, and if he
    doesn't vote, it will be as a Board member simply observing.
[2] I'm guessing that AT&T views their interests primarily as a technology
    company rather than as a marks rights holder, hence my placing Marilyn
    and Mark in the "yes" column.
[3] Matt Hooker goes into the "no" column, cc'ing wildly that voting is not
    proper.

15, perhaps 12 "yes" votes, 5 perhaps 7 "no" votes. 

Total: 50-45 "yes", 12-17 "no" votes, and 40 non-voting.
A 3-1 or 4-1 margin with over 50% of the participants participating.

Next anticipated process challenges:

	1. that the non-responsive comatose moribund opinionless feckless		   listdreck by existence make the 50 votes only 45% "yes", hence
	   the vote not a valid tool for WG self-management.
	2. that lack of notice prior to holding a vote (Hooker's lament)
	   precludes the vote from being  a valid tool for WG self-management.

Cheers,
Eric