ICANN/DNSO
DNSO Mailling lists archives

[nc-udrp]


<<< Chronological Index >>>    <<< Thread Index >>>

[nc-udrp] Responses Summary


Title: Responses Summary

I have attached a summary of responses 132-140.  In the summaries I have used the self-identification of the responses, although one could probably have aligned some responses differently.

I have only a few comments.

Consistent with other members of the Task Force, I was somewhat frustrated with the small sample.  I would not like to draw too much from the responses, and certainly not from the sample of nine responses that I have summarized.  Perhaps when our individual summaries are aggregated, there may be some clearer indications of opinion.

The two most narrative responses (135-136) each appeared to have had their submissions terminated in mid-stream, which only exacerbated my frustration.

As a result, I echo comments by others that we need to go beyond what we see in the surveys, and discuss the issues more generally, drawing on the many thoughtful commentaries and studies that are out there.  I look forward to that discussion, which I hope will make good use of the many talents that reside among our group.

Graeme

 

UDRP Review Chart Surveys (GBD).doc



<<< Chronological Index >>>    <<< Thread Index >>>