Re: [nc-udrp] UDRP Survey Analysis Chart

[Dan Steinberg <synthesis@videotron.ca>]

well I figure if people I respect have chosen this format, why bother
even trying to re-invent the wheel? So I will follow as well. Just...not
till tomorrow at this rate.

"J. Scott Evans" wrote:

> Dear All: They say that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
> Accordingly, Katrina please consider yourself flattered.  I simply
> took Katrina's format and style of analysis and applied it to my eight
> questions. ;-). I do have some comments for the group.  First, Milton,
> Caroline, on a couple of the questions which required the respondent
> to rank the choice, I received all choice equally ranked as no. 1.
> Would this occur if the respondent failed to make any choices?   I
> only ask the because these two forms were only sparsely completed.  I
> just wonder about integrity here. Second, I suggest that everyone look
> to question seven first.  Two my respondents identified themselves as
> "complainants" and on question seven stated that they were counsel for
> the complainant in a UDRP action.  So much for clear instructions. My
> responses were only surprising in that, overall, the respondents all
> seem to be rather happy with the UDRP as it stands.  There was a
> uniform call to amend 4(a)(iii) to read "registered or used in bad
> faith."  I was also surprised that the majority of respondents did not
> want an appeals process built into the UDRP.  In addition, the
> majority of respondents felt that a complainant shooed be able to
> reply to a response or amend a complaint if circumstance warrant such
> steps.  Equally, all seemed to feel that a respondent should have some
> leeway to react to chaining circumstances. Overall, I felt the results
> were positive; however, you can review the chart I prepared and judge
> for yourselves. Hope all is well. Regards. J. Scott Evans
> ADAMS, SCHWARTZ & EVANS, P.A.
> jse@adamspat.com
> 704-375-9249

--
Dan Steinberg

SYNTHESIS:Law & Technology
35, du Ravin  phone: (613) 794-5356
Chelsea, Quebec  fax:   (819) 827-4398
J9B 1N1                 e-mail:synthesis@videotron.ca