[nc-review] Draft interim report Review
Milton and Roberto,
I do not want to damn a whole report covering several issues
because TF members have reservations about some of the majority views on certain
issues. I have included all non-conflictual comments. In order to get task force
agreement to the report I propose adding a section for minority views and to
summarise your views as follows. Please let me have your support to the report
with this addition - and a reply today (Monday Oct 8) would be
wonderful!.
Philip.
Minority viewpoints
Two task force members had alternative opinions on certain
points.
GA Chair
The representative of the GA believed the by-law requirement
and practise whereby the NC sanctions the election result of the
GA chair should be abolished.
New constituencies
The representative of the GA, while not dismissing the
proposed criteria, believed that that the creation of new
constituencies should have no higher burden than the creation of initial
constituencies.
The representative of the NCDNHC proposed the new criteria
should be applied retroactively to all constituencies, if they were to apply to
new ones.
The representative of the NCDNHC proposed making the GA itself
a DNSO constituency to represent individuals.
Consensus
The representative of the GA preferred the term "working group
consensus" in place of "majority vote of the working group".
|