Re: [Fwd: [ga] [Admin] Restoration of posting rights for Jeff Williams]

[Mark Measday <measday@josmarian.ch>]

Roberto,

Quite, Roberto.

Therefore JW should be reinstated.

According to Harald, there was some complaint of slander, slander uttered by JW of a Mr Cohen, whether Josh, Joe, Jonathan, Benjamin or another is unclear from the context of the particular email.

This is neither proven nor substantiated, although it might well have been if Harald had followed appropriate procedures. Therefore JW should be reinstated.

Should there be a complaint (which I understand there is not) for some offence against list etiquette, then perhaps JW should be suspended. When it is it should be examined carefully.

If you start eliminating people on suspicion they have done something wrong, you soon descend into lynch law, a perversion of justice which can soon be turned round against you.

I agree the principle should be possibly tested in some civil action, rather than burdening you and Harald with the responsibility. One hopes that either JW or his adversary would initiate a resolution.

However, pending such a hypothetical outcome, he should be reinstated as he is not culpable of the offence for which he was suspended.

I am surprised that a man as sophisticated as yourself should balance his reputation oin such a matter.
 

Roberto Gaetano wrote:

Mark,

>
>Having no view on this, and rather wishing I had nothing to do with it,
 you
>should either challenge JW to produce his evidence, request the
gentleman
>concerned formally to rebut the allegations by bringing some action
against JW
>to refute him, or restore JW to the list.
>
>Not to do so is an arbitrary misuse of your position.
>

I am afraid you are missing the point.

The purpose of this list is not to discuss hypothetical or even real
court cases or individual behaviours unrelated to Domain Names issues.
For this purpose, there may be other lists, or other fora.

Whoever wants to continue this argument, or to discuss the behaviour of
other individuals (with or without close or remote involvment with the
DNSO), or continue offending eachother, is most than welcome to move the
 discussion to more appropriate places of his/her choice, and keep this
place for strictly DNSO-related issues.

In case I had to interpret your message as an appeal for the List
Manager decision, please be aware that, as Chair, I consider his
decision fully in order.

Thanks
Roberto

--
Mark Measday
__________________________________________________________________________

Josmarian SA (Switzerland) Josmarian (UK) Ltd
http://www.josmarian.ch measday@josmarian.ch
UK tel/fax: 0044.1273.47.48.94  UK mobile: 0044.370.947.420
French tel/fax: 0033.450.20.94.92

'Tragedy inheres in all choice' : Isaiah Berlin
__________________________________________________________________________
 

begin:vcard 
n:Measday;Mark
tel;cell:0044370947420
tel;fax:0033450209492
tel;home:00441273474894
tel;work:0033450209492
x-mozilla-html:TRUE
url:http://www.josmarian.ch
org:Josmarian SA
version:2.1
email;internet:measday@josmarian.ch
title:Director
adr;quoted-printable:;;pa Reich & Zen-Ruffinen=0D=0A72 bd St Georges=0D=0A=0D=0A;Geneva;;CH-1205;Switzerland
note;quoted-printable:Josmarian is a swiss virtual rights consultancy company specialising =0D=0Ain advice to international companies and  institutions on appropriate legal and technical =0D=0Astrategies to transition from bilateral or multilateral internationalist to thinking globalist. 
fn:Mark Measday
end:vcard